The Niche-Down Racket Is Live
/Should you niche down? Mostly no. The advice pays the people selling it more reliably than the people taking it. I tore the whole aisle down: the formula sellers, the deep-work gurus, the counter-gurus, and the one honest argument worth keeping. Free, no email wall.
TL;DR: Seven guides merged into five field manuals, a START HERE shelf on the guides page, and a new anchor piece that takes the niche-advice industry apart desk by desk. The Niche-Down Racket is live. Free, long, no email wall.
Spent the week in the guides shelf with a wrecking bar.
Seven of my guides were fighting each other for the same searches. Two pricing guides with nearly the same name, two newsletter guides splitting one job between them, three short-form guides saying overlapping things at overlapping lengths.
Google looks at that and picks nobody. So I merged them into five field manuals, lost nothing but the repetition, and pointed the old addresses at the new homes. The guides page now opens with the field manuals themselves: the anchor guides everything else hangs off.
Then I wrote the piece the shelf was missing.
Every operator I know got handed the same commandment on day one: niche down. Pick a lane. The riches are in the niches.
I obeyed it once. Niched this whole site into writing for profit, and six weeks later I dreaded opening the laptop. The thing I had loved since I was fourteen, wearing a lanyard.
So the new manual does what I wish somebody had done for me back then. It traces where the advice came from, and the trail is older and stranger than the gurus know.
Kevin Kelly was writing about a “niche of one” in 1998, and he meant a market of one, a product built for a single customer. The industry flipped a claim about manufacturing into identity surgery and priced it as a course.
Three desks run the racket now. The formula sellers with their fill-in-the-blank positioning sentences. The deep-work gurus, whose philosophy only runs on rent that’s already handled. And the counter-gurus selling the backlash, which is the same cage with the word “authenticity” painted on the bars.
The piece takes each one apart and keeps the single honest tool worth stealing on the way out.
Full manual: The Niche-Down Racket: Who Gets Paid When You Pick a Lane.
Read it with one hand on your wallet. That rule covers me too.
Comments are open to members. Sign up free →